Reckless Nani ruins Manchester United's chance to go top

Premier League

Aston Villa 1	Cuellar 19
Manchester United 1	Collins (og) 23

Nani stares in disbelief as the referee holds up the red card for his challenge on Stilian Petrov. Photograph: Laurence Griffiths/Getty ImagesManchester United kept their poise in a match that could have been unbalanced by the red card for the visitors' winger Nani. He was sent off by the referee Peter Walton for a jumping, two-footed challenge on Stilian Petrov in the 23rd minute.The score stood at 1-1 then but the visitors adapted well to take this a useful draw that brings them to within a point of the leaders Chelsea, who were beaten at Goodison Park.Despite the joy in United's ranks, Nani's offence cannot be disregarded. At a juncture in the season when the leading clubs usually muster all their know-how and poise, Nani succumbed to an inexplicable recklessness.

In an inconsequential midfield area, he launched himself into a brutal, two-footed challenge on the Villa captain. Sir Alex Ferguson has commented on the recent improvement since the 23-year-old grew out of the shyness of youth. It would have been better for Nani if he had retained a little of the wallflower tendency here.There had been a mistaken belief that this game would have a subdued character. Villa's scoring ratio, after all, has been little better than a goal a game in the Premier League.The club probably appreciate that a prolific attacker is hard enough to identify and almost impossible to obtain, considering how prized such a figure must be in the transfer market.When a striker already on the books, such as Emile Heskey, is injured and another, John Carew is on the bench after his back problems, there is a grave risk of harmlessness.A football match, all the same, has a haphazard streak and Villa took the lead with a goal born of randomness that ended in a fine piece of deliberation. In the 19th minute, Stewart Downing's inswinging cross from the right took a deflection, struck Rafael, looped into the air and was then headed deftly over the goalkeeper Edwin van der Sar by Cuéllar. Villa had scored on an evening when they seemed to lack firepower but then lacked the resilience expected of them.

United were level four minutes later. Nani, in a valuable moment in his cameo outing, crossed from the right and a shrewd Giggs held his position towards the back post while others clustered in the middle. The Welshman was therefore in space for a shot that deflected off the centre-half James Collins for an unlucky own goal. The next piece of haphazardness took place in the mind of Nani as he committed that red card offence.Both sides seemed startled in the aftermath. Villa were too sensible to suppose they should hurtle themselves at opponents with the acumen of United. Ferguson's side contains enough know-how not to be thrown off course by adversity. A 4-4-1 formation was adapted.That system is not so anodyne as it seems when the lone striker is Wayne Rooney. There was a flicker of panic when Giggs picked him out in the 41st minute but the veteran goalkeeper Brad Friedel showed his anticipation by racing out to clear.Both sides, before the interval, seemed to be more wary after Nani left the pitch. It made sense for an outnumbered United to be circumspect. Villa, for their part, tried to avoid being gung-ho simply because they had superior numbers. The calibre of even a depleted United still made them pensive.

The adaptation to circumstances continued with the replacement of the veteran Paul Scholes by Antonio Valencia, who had the appropriate speed and vigour for the situation. If anything, the imbalance of forces looked as if it was more likely to make Villa wobble. They did not appear wholly sure of how they should conduct themselves.Attacking flurries were more common from United immediately after the interval. Villa, if anything, seemed nonplussed by the opportunity that had dropped into their laps. There was a glimpse of the quality in Martin O'Neill's side, when James Milner eluded Wes Brown for a shot that then called for nothing more than a simple save by Van der Sar.The tone was not acceptable and the Villa manager took off the holding midfielder Fabian Delph and introduced John Carew. United showed no sign of being deterred. In the 63rd minute Giggs picked out Rooney and the forward escaped Collins before shooting high from an angle. Villa had not intentionally curbed themselves.

They moved downfield in numbers but seldom found the imaginative touch that would have left United in disarray. Even without Scholes on the scene, United still drew from a deep well of experience.There was enough faith, too, for Ferguson to send on another centre-forward to join Rooney when Giggs was taken off. Almost immediately, Rooney's curling effort had to be tipped over the bar by Friedel as the match continued to be hard-fought.